PROPERTY TAX IN THE NEWS – NOVEMBER 2026
IPTI’s usual monthly newsletter – the “President’s Message” – contains, inter alia, a number of
summarised news articles from around the world. This IPTI publication – “Property Tax in the News”
– contains some of the more interesting news articles concerning property taxes in North America
and Europe which is where many of our members have a particular interest. Links to these and more,
similarly summarised, articles – from North America, Europe and around the globe – can be found
in “IPTI Xtracts” on our website: www.ipti.org. Please note that these are news articles; they do not
necessarily reflect IPTI’s views.
USA
Property Tax Revolt Succeeds in Florida; Fails in Wyoming and Oklahoma
Five states approved property tax cuts – but cutting taxes is easier than cutting the cost of
government.
Last night, voters in seven states were asked whether they wanted to reduce property taxes
through statewide ballot initiatives. Voters in Florida, North Carolina, Louisiana, Tennessee, and
Georgia said yes, while those in Wyoming and Oklahoma said no.
These ballot proposals follow dozens of property tax relief measures enacted in recent years in
states like Texas, Ohio, and North Dakota.
Among the property tax proposals on ballots this Tuesday, Florida’s Amendment 3 was the most
consequential. The proposal, which was at one point called “Save Our Homes from Excessive
Property Taxes,” will exempt the first $250,000 of a primary home’s value from non-school district
property taxes by 2028, with the exemption level adjusted for inflation going forward. The proposal
also limits how much assessed values of nonprimary residences can rise each year, lowering the cap
from 10 percent to 5 percent.
The initiative passed with 62 percent of the vote, with 60 percent support needed to pass. The
Florida Legislature’s Revenue Estimating Conference (REC), a nonpartisan panel of state
economists, estimated that by 2028, when the new exemption is fully implemented, it will reduce
property tax revenues by $12 billion annually statewide. Comparing REC’s estimates against Reason
Foundation’s city and county revenue data, the impact expected by 2028 amounts to about 10
percent of what Florida’s counties collected in 2024, and 6 percent of what its cities collected.
Wyoming voters said no to a similar measure. Initiative 1 would have exempted half of a primary
residence’s home value from property taxes. The state already exempts 25 percent of a primary
residence’s value, up to $1 million.
Page | 2
In Oklahoma, voters rejected State Question 847, which would have lowered the maximum amount
taxable property values can increase each year.
Meanwhile, North Carolina passed a constitutional amendment requiring the state legislature to
limit how much local governments could increase their total property tax collections.
Tennessee passed Amendment 2, which outright prohibits the state government from levying
property taxes. The state had already repealed its state-level property tax in 1949, but the
prohibition is now enshrined in the state constitution. (Local governments can still levy property
taxes.)
Louisiana voters approved four narrow reforms that expand property tax exemptions for seniors,
surviving spouses of disabled veterans, as well as eligibility for property assessment freezes. Voters
rejected two other proposals: one allowing tax exemptions for rehabilitated properties and another
giving local governments greater flexibility to raise property tax rates without seeking additional
voter approval.
Georgia approved Amendment 1, which expands the preferential property tax treatment for
agricultural and timberland properties.
Why is there such a push for property tax relief now? Heightened inflation, years of low interest
rates, and the growth of remote work during the COVID-19 pandemic contributed to a nationwide
surge in home prices. The effects were especially pronounced in areas that attracted large numbers
of new residents during the pandemic, many of which are red states. For example, the Texas
comptroller reported that median home prices in the state increased by 40 percent between 2019
and 2023.
Another factor was that state and local governments emerged from the pandemic with a stronger
fiscal position. During the pandemic, Congress provided hundreds of billions in additional federal aid
to state and local governments through the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES)
Act and the American Rescue Plan, along with substantial additional aid for specific programs. This,
combined with strong tax collections, helped produce large operating surpluses and improve
government balance sheets.
As some homeowners have increasingly struggled with rising tax bills, many of their governments
have accumulated savings. It is hardly surprising that many voters are revolting. But there is an
important distinction between reducing taxes and reducing the cost of government.
Supporters of these ballot measures hope that restricting property tax revenues will force their
cities, counties, and school districts to cut unnecessary spending. But property taxes are the largest
source of revenue that America’s local governments raise themselves, accounting for roughly 44
percent of that revenue, compared with only 9 percent from sales taxes. Given the scale of the
revenue involved, significantly reducing or abolishing property taxes would require major spending
cuts or corresponding reductions in the services local governments are expected to provide.
Page | 3
Focusing on tax cuts, rather than spending cuts, may not produce the savings taxpayers expect.
Instead of reducing the cost and scope of operations, local governments are more likely to
compensate for foregone property tax revenue by raising sales taxes or other taxes, requesting
additional transfers from their state governments or Washington, or deferring expenditures and
issuing more debt.
This is not to say tax limits are not a legitimate constraint on government growth. But they are
generally more effective in preventing spending growth than reducing established spending. If
lawmakers and taxpayers want local governments to cost significantly less, they must first decide
which responsibilities to shed and where spending can be reduced.
Otherwise, taxpayers may be surprised to find that the tax relief they received on one end has
reappeared on the other.
Missouri: Auditor calls Jackson County’s 2023 property reassessments a ‘catastrophic failure’
Missouri State Auditor Scott Fitzpatrick characterized the 2023 Jackson County property
reassessment as a “catastrophic failure” while detailing the results of an audit of the county’s
Assessment Department and reassessment process Friday in Kansas City.
He says the audit revealed systemic failures that led to more than 200,000 illegal assessments and
severely harmed taxpayers.
The audit assigned the lowest possible rating to the previous leadership under Gail McCann Beatty,
citing failures in leadership, planning, oversight and accountability.
Key issues listed in the audit included:
• disregard for statutory requirements such as percentage limits on valuation increases
• improper classification of parcel reviews as physical inspections
• inadequate and legally insufficient taxpayer notifications, with over 49,000 taxpayers not
notified by the statutory deadline
• flawed inspection practices, including many conducted remotely or in under five minutes
without proper documentation
Also stated in the audit, the department’s claim that properties were significantly undervalued was
contradicted by 2021 assessments already exceeding state targets, indicating that incremental
reassessments could have sufficed.
Fitzpatrick said that, despite knowing they could not meet legal notice requirements, leadership
pressed forward with inadequate and undated notices, reflecting incompetence or stubbornness.
Page | 4
The audit faced unprecedented resistance, including legal battles and subpoenas to obtain
necessary records from the county and contractors like Data Cloud Solutions, delaying the report’s
release until 2026 and increasing costs for taxpayers.
Nevertheless, the audit provided critical evidence that led the State Tax Commission to cap
valuation increases at 15% and implement a tax credit program.
He noted that current county leadership under County Executive Phil Levota has taken steps to
implement recommendations and comply with rollback orders.
Fitzpatrick praised the county legislature and executive for their cooperation and emphasized the
need for a fair, transparent, and lawful assessment process to prevent recurrence.
Regarding accountability, Fitzpatrick noted that while criminal charges would require evidence of
fraud or unjust enrichment, the primary consequence was the firing of the former assessor.
The audit revealed unprecedented mismanagement affecting hundreds of thousands of taxpayers
and potentially hundreds of millions of dollars.
The reassessment process began under public scrutiny in Aug. 2023 and was prioritized due to
appeal deadlines.
The report’s recommendations focus on proper notice, statutory compliance in inspections, and
thorough documentation, all largely accepted by the county.
Fitzpatrick feels that while significant progress has been made, the resolution process, including tax
credits and settlements, will continue over several years and that Jackson County is on the path to
rectifying the reassessment failures and improving the property tax system for its residents.
CANADA
Saskatchewan Assessment Management Agency Operating Effectively: Independent Review
The Government of Saskatchewan recognizes the importance of maintaining a fair, stable and
efficient property assessment and taxation system that serves the interests of municipalities and
property owners, within the province’s four-year property revaluation cycle.
To support the government’s responsibilities, the Ministry of Government Relations engaged
Upfront Consulting to conduct an independent review of the Saskatchewan Assessment
Management Agency (SAMA) governance structure and ratepayer representation, with a focus on
transparency and consultation.
Page | 5
SAMA is an independent agency responsible for maintaining a stable, current and reliable property
assessment system for Saskatchewan. Its responsibilities include developing assessment policies
and standards, providing property valuation services, auditing assessments and confirming
municipal assessment rolls. The agency is responsible for a property assessment base valued at
more than $278 billion, supporting the fair distribution of approximately $2.63 billion in annual
municipal and education property taxes.
The review found that SAMA is operating effectively and has the professional competence and
management capacity to carry out its mandate. It also identified several opportunities to strengthen
governance and stakeholder participation. The review results are being released publicly on
Saskatchewan.ca.
“Fair and transparent property assessments are the foundation of Saskatchewan’s property tax
system, and SAMA plays a key role in upholding these principles,” Government Relations Minister
Eric Schmalz said. “This review provides practical recommendations to support stakeholder
participation and build on SAMA’s strengths.”
“SAMA is an organization that strives to be transparent and open to feedback,” SAMA CEO Shaun
Cooney said. “Having Upfront Consulting review our governance structure was a welcome
opportunity to confirm that the agency is operating at a high level for our clients and stakeholders.”
The review identified four areas for improvement: board member appointments, advisory
committees, stakeholder engagement and conflict of interest guidelines.
The Government of Saskatchewan provides legislative and policy oversight of the province’s
property assessment system while respecting SAMA’s independent governance and operational
responsibilities.
A summary of the final report is available at Saskatchewan.ca
EUROPE
Denmark: 30,000 owner-occupied apartments to get lower property valuations
The Danish government plans to introduce legislation that would lower property assessments for
approximately 30,100 owner-occupied apartments across 31 municipalities, preventing
homeowners from facing disproportionately high property taxes.
Minister for Taxation and Growth Jakob Engel-Schmidt said the proposal would ensure that
property valuations better reflect local housing market conditions rather than price developments
in larger cities.
The issue affects municipalities with too few apartment sales to calculate reliable local price indexes.
In 82 of Denmark’s 98 municipalities, insufficient sales data currently prevents Statistics Denmark
from producing such indexes.
On Bornholm, for example, apartment valuations risk being influenced by housing price increases in
Copenhagen, despite significant differences between the two markets.
Under the proposal, the Danish Assessment Agency would instead use local price developments for
single-family houses when these produce lower valuations. If local data is unavailable, the agency
would apply the regional index resulting in the lowest price projection.
The legislation would also generally exempt apartment owners in the island municipalities of Samsø,
Fanø, Læsø and Ærø from price increases in their assessments this year.
The proposed changes would apply through 2027, although Engel-Schmidt said he intends to extend
the system if no better alternative is developed.
UK: Are business rates still fit for purpose?
Business (non-domestic) rates originated as a 16th century tax.
Whilst business rates have changed a little over the intervening centuries, the basic concept of a
property tax still holds true.
But in the 21st century the nature of business operations, their relationship to place and the reliance
(or not) on physical sites have altered fundamentally. Those ‘left behind’ at the margins of this
global corporate world such as small businesses and town centres receive a raw deal from the rates
and taxation approaches we take.
The shifting nature of business (global, tax havens, online, out-of-town, gig economy) has
transformed the taxation landscape. The previous links between taxation, responsibility, authority,
representation and place at a local (or often a national) level have been dismantled.
The purposes and intentions behind local property taxation have been long forgotten and the role
of business taxation in any economy has become subject to increasing questioning if not outright
avoidance.
As these shifts have happened, so the non-domestic rates system has become more complex, often
because of special pleading or specific schemes, and those paying it subject to ever more hurdles
and volatility. It is often perceived as unfair, disproportionate and complicated, with ‘cliff edges’ and
perverse disincentives, including against scale, growth and town centre locations. The operation of
the non-domestic rates system is viewed as inconsistent and is likely inefficient and increasingly
ineffective. At a time of public sector reform and increasing need for efficiency and effectiveness,
business rate approaches and practices are ripe for reconsideration.
We persist with non-domestic rates because they bring in a relatively predictable and large tax
revenue, have a nominal relationship to place and because few can agree on exactly how to reform
the system. Part of the reason for the latter is that almost every sector or their trade organisations,
are asking for special treatment (retailers, hospitality, booksellers, cultural sites, education, charities
and so on); requests that multiply and expand each year.
Non-domestic rates are seen in isolation, rather than as one component of a country’s taxation
raising and any justifiable contribution that business should make. We have to ask what is the
twenty-first century purpose of non-domestic rates?
If Scottish policy is to promote communities and Community Wealth Building, local organisations,
small businesses, growth opportunities and entrepreneurship, particularly in town centres, then
non-domestic rates need to align with and deliver this. Too often they seem to be an impediment.
The rates system needs simplification and consistency and to provide incentives for local growth
rather than barriers to it.
Likewise, the cost of renovating buildings is less than developing new ones or knocking down and
replacing old ones. VAT rates and allowances run in the wrong direction if we are seeking to maintain
our heritage assets and a sense of place.
If we want to support town centres, then why do we have rates at all for qualifying businesses or
buildings located within them (local, small, co-operative, community) irrespective of the sector. This
should be automatic, as in other forms of tax zones, and paid for by improving and sorting out our
approaches and practices and by recognising the harm some activities do to town centres,
communities, places and policy goals and treating them appropriately in terms of rates and taxation.
Leigh Sparks is professor of Retail Studies at the University of Stirling and runs a blog
(stirlingretail.com) where he has written for a long time on the problem of rates.
UK: Free-entry museums to benefit from new business rates policy after landmark tribunal ruling
Institutions across England expected to see significant reductions thanks to change in Valuation
Office approach
Free-to-enter museums and galleries across England will benefit from significant reductions in their
business rates valuations following a landmark legal case won by London’s Natural History Museum
earlier this year.
In an update to sector stakeholders, the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS)
confirmed that the Valuation Office (VO) would no longer use a notional receipts approach to value
free-to-enter museums for business rates purposes.
The change follows the outcome of a tribunal brought by the Natural History Museum against the
VO.
The tribunal accepted the argument that the museum operates at a loss to preserve collections and
remain open to the public, and should not be valued as though it were a profitable commercial
property because no commercial tenant would take on such a letting.
Previously, the VO had used the receipts and expenditure method to estimate museums’ rateable
values, analysing their income and expenditure. For free-to-enter museums with limited income
beyond external funding, this included calculating “notional receipts” based on a potential
admission charge and visitor numbers.
The approach was based on earlier Upper Tribunal decisions concerning museums. However,
following the latest tribunal ruling, the VO will no longer use notional receipts to value museums
and galleries where the method has been applied.
The VO was previously a separate government agency but was integrated into HM Revenue and
Customs (HMRC) in April. An HMRC spokesman said: “A Valuation Tribunal decision on the National
History Museum, which is free-to-enter, did not approve of the use of notional receipts in calculating
its rateable value. This represents a change in rating case law which we must reflect across the
museums and art galleries sector for properties where notional receipts have been used in the
property’s assessment.
“Therefore, we will cease using ‘notional receipts’ for museums and art galleries, and consider only
the actual receipts.”
Following the change, the VO is reviewing assessments that are currently valued as museums and
art galleries, and will amend both the 2023 and 2026 rating lists by 31 March 2027. For the 2023 list,
any resulting changes will apply from 1 April 2023.
The HMRC spokesman said: “The amendments will be communicated to the local council who will
then be responsible for recalculating bills. The VO will contact individual ratepayers if their rateable
value is amended.”
Museums that have already contacted the VO via the Check, Challenge and Appeal process (CCA)
will be contacted through the CCA system as part of the review, the spokesman said.
The 2026 Rating List contains 1,165 museum and gallery properties with a combined rateable value
of approximately £135m. DCMS expects the aggregate rateable value of the sector to fall
significantly as a result of the change.
However, the impact on actual business rates liabilities will be smaller than the headline figure
suggests, as many affected properties already benefit from charitable relief or discretionary relief
granted by their local council.
And although many museums are likely to see their rateable value fall to £1, HMRC said some would
retain a higher valuation where their receipts and expenditure showed a surplus. It said the VO will
also use reliable rental evidence where available, which it considers the most accurate indicator of
a property’s rateable value.
DCMS said the change would nevertheless deliver meaningful savings for many free-to-enter
museums and galleries.
The department acknowledged that museums had raised concerns about their business rates
valuations over several years, and said the tribunal case had secured the clear precedent necessary
to bring about the change.
The Natural History Museum was the first national museum to win a business rates tribunal,
following earlier legal victories by three regional institutions: Exeter’s Royal Albert Memorial
Museum, Tyne and Wear Archives and Museums (now North East Museums), and York Museum and
Gallery Trust.
The announcement has been welcomed by museum sector bodies.
Sharon Heal, the director of the Museums Association (MA), said: “We’re delighted by this decision,
which reflects that museums are not profitable commercial properties.
“The MA has been working with other sector bodies to call for a fair and consistent business rates
system for museums so we warmly welcome this change which will result in significant savings for
free-to-enter museums in England at a time when many are facing financial challenges.”
Emmie Kell, the director of museums and cultural property at Arts Council England, said she was
“delighted to see this positive development for museums and galleries across England”.
“The VO has confirmed a significant change to the way free-to-enter museums are valued for
business rates purposes,” Kell said.
“For many organisations, this will reduce rateable values substantially and create welcome savings
at a time when financial resilience remains a major challenge for the sector.
“Museums have been raising concerns about this issue for many years, so it’s encouraging to see a
solution emerge through government action following the Natural History Museum tribunal case.
Thank you to colleagues across government for responding positively to this long-standing sector
concern.
“This is a practical intervention that will help museums direct more of their resources towards
serving communities, caring for collections and inspiring future generations.”
Lisa Ollerhead, the director of the Association of Independent Museums, said the change in
approach was “a massive and important step that will free up so much money that’s been circling
for years between museums, councils, public funders, and tribunals”.
However she cautioned that the news “isn’t necessarily a total victory”, saying the new approach
should be extended to charging museums as well.
“We’re looking at what it means for the sector generally,” said Ollerhead. “But it is a major
acknowledgement that, for ratings purposes, museums aren’t in it to make money, and that counts
for ones that meet their public purposes through operating models that feature charging as well as
those that don’t.”